This article concludes with guidelines for other healthcare provider organizations to capture the benefits of the balanced scorecard performance management. The efficacy of the balanced scorecard approach to health care. Applying the balanced scorecard in healthcare provider organ. The methodology relies on a participative case study performed by external researchers in close collaboration with the staff of. The following white paper includes sample scorecards with examples to illustrate how medical and healthcare groups have put the balanced scorecard to work for them. In the everchanging world of health care, identifying the customer becomes more complex each year.
It aligns the organization around a more marketoriented, customerfocused strategy it facilitates, monitors, and assesses the implementation of the strategy it provides a communication and collaboration mechanism it assigns accountability for performance at all levels of the organization it provides continual feedback on the strategy and promotes adjustments to. The balanced scorecard in healthcare clearpoint strategy. Balanced performance measurement in research hospitals. They have been trying to apply any tools and methods available for measuring and improving the performance of management in specific areas of health and health care. Since then, use of the balanced scorecard has grown dramatically as a key strategic management system and is now widely recognised internationally. An approach such as a balanced scorecard allows for a comprehensive analysis of domains that are deemed important in achieving the overall vision of the health system. To what extent has the balanced scorecard been introduced in healthcare. The healthcare scorecard enhances healthcare management by providing key performance indicators that enable healthcare organizations to effectively manage their organization performance by enabling them to. A healthcare balanced scorecard example unlike the other examples above, this strategy map begins with a purpose statement. The bsc is a management tool, originally applied to businesses in the private sector, developed by kaplan and norton in 1992. Before presenting balanced scorecard examples, it is important to understand the context and the concepts behind the management and monitoring tool created by professors robert s. How a public sector agency reinvigorated its balanced scorecard. The balanced scorecard as a strategic performance management tool provides a comprehensive set of financial and nonfinancial performance measures for the healthcare organizations to be strategy.
Application of bsc method in healthcare organizations is also described by. Introduction as popular performance measurement tools, the balanced scorecard bsc has been widely used for more than two decades. The paper contributes to the body of literature on the application of the balanced scorecard in healthcare. Applying the balanced scorecard in healthcare provider organizations. The scorecards measurement and management system provides the following potential benefits to healthcare organizations. A balanced scorecard is a strategic management tool that was first suggested by robert kaplan and david norton in 1992. Application of balanced scorecard in the evaluation of a. Adapting the balanced scorecard into the healthcare industry. Today the term customer encompasses various managed care organizations, thirdparty pay. For many hospitals and healthcare providers, the customer category has become the most important category in the balanced scorecard, particularly as it relates to physicians, as the economic. The scorecard includes measures voluntarily reported by states, as well as federally reported measures in three pillars state health system performance, state administrative.
An application of balanced scorecard in healthcare organizations. Not all organizations do this, but this may be helpful for healthcare organizations who need to place additional emphasis on what is most critical to them and what theyre trying to achieve. Implementing a balanced scorecard as a strategic management tool in a longterm care organization. In the past few years a growing number of healthcare provider organizations have adopted the balanced scorecard bsc framework to develop a more comprehensive set of performance indicators. Balanced scorecard means different things to different people. Applications of the balanced scorecard for strategic.
Applying a balanced scorecard to health care organizations applying a balanced scorecard to health care organizations stewart, louis j bestor, william e. All nine organizations were in the early stages of implementing their bscs. Applying a balanced scorecard to health care organizations. Canadian blood services is a national, notforprofit organization that manages the supply of blood and blood products in all provinces and territories outside of quebec. This paper focuses on the performance of healthcare organizations using balanced scorecard method bsc. Healthcare organizations can be described as based on three domains related to policy, administrative management, and professional services. Organizational structure and performances of responsible. In the study, it is suggested that if healthcare organizations use the balanced scorecard as a performance management system, it may facilitate them to be strategy focused and may better serve. Abstract executive summary several innovative healthcare executives have recently introduced a new business strategy implementation tool. The competitiveness and balanced scorecard of health care companies 3 creating competitive advantage swayne, duncan, ginter, 2006 is often a matter of selecting an appropriate basis on which to compete, it is the means by which the organization seeks to develop cost advantage or to differentiate itself from other organizations. Ultimately, the hospitals management implemented a balanced scorecard. A full balanced scorecard example including 6 templates. Some of the most significant benefits that part of the companies who have successfully implemented the bsc methodology agreed upon are listed as follows. Review of the use of the balanced scorecard in healthcare 19.
It aligns the organization around a more marketoriented, customerfocused strategy it facilitates, monitors, and. Balanced scorecard will provide goals and standards for. Balanced scorecard the efficacy of the balanced scorecard approach to health care health care organizations are composed of several departments that contribute, in theory, to the unified mission of quality health services that enable patients to return to a condition of wellness. We surveyed executives in nine provider organizations that were implementing the balanced scorecard. Adapting the balanced scorecard into the healthcare. At one extreme, a measurementbased balanced scorecard is simply a performance measurement framework for grouping existing measures into categories, and displaying the measures graphically, usually as a dashboard. Research has shown that organisations that use a balanced scorecard approach tend to outperform organisations without a formal approach to strategic performance management. The balance scorecard implementation in the italian health. The balanced scorecard can revolutionize your healthcare strategy and wed like to help you get started.
Less common are surveys about applying bsc in health care. Its goals were to help translate the vision for the hospital and to gain consensus. A balanced scorecard provides a way to look at an organization from four perspectives by developing benchmarks and collecting and analyzing data relative to those perspectives. The hospitals balanced scorecard consists of one composite. Nursing leadership within healthcare organizations across the continuum consider the challenges a nurse faces when transitioning to a management position. Using the balanced scorecard to align your organization.
Therefore, the results are only sugges tive about the potential value of the scorecard for healthcare organizations. A strategic management system for multisector collaboration and strategy implementation. Development of a balanced scorecard in a department of. Implementing a balanced scorecard as a strategic management tool in a longterm care organization show all authors. A balanced scorecard or strategy planning a software that works outofthebox. Applying the balanced scorecard to local public health. Applying the balanced scorecard in healthcare provider. The balance scorecard implementation in the italian health care system. Request pdf applying the balanced scorecard in healthcare provider organizations several innovative healthcare executives have recently introduced a. Pdf the balanced scorecard for the healthcare organizations.
The balanced scorecard, first proposed in the januaryfebruary 1992 issue of hbr the balanced scorecardmeasures that drive performance, provides executives with a comprehensive. Introduction the first article on the balanced scorecard was published in 1992 by kaplan and norton kaplan and norton, 1992. Before the advent of medicare,health care facilities customers were only patients and physicians. Pdf applying the balanced scorecard in healthcare provider. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view. Bsc designer balanced scorecard software free plan. Some evidences from literature and a case study analysis. Ebscohost serves thousands of libraries with premium essays, articles and other content including applying the balanced scorecard in healthcare provider organizations.
The paper tried to entangle the current puzzle on the implementation of the balanced scorecard, especially within a healthservice provider. This paper fulfills a need by healthcare providers to obtain information on implementing a balanced scorecard system that specifically addresses issues unique to hospitals. In time, the benefits of the balanced scorecard have been identified by many organizations which have successfully implemented this tool. The role of the balanced scorecard in relation to a welldefined vision, mission, and strategy 2.
The next section will deliberate on the balanced scorecard. Use of the balanced scorecard in health care william n. Matthias since kaplan and norton published their article proposing a balanced scorecard the concept has been widely adopted by industry and health care provider organizations. Review of the use of the balanced scorecard in healthcare 1 1. Organization and it department use a single tool to measure performance therefore have a common language, and planning and it evaluation integration will facilitate. Balanced scorecard ahrq digital healthcare research. The competitiveness and balanced the competitiveness. Executive summary several innovative healthcare executives have recently introduced a new business. In terms of harvard professor robert simons control systems scheme, the balanced scorecard is a diagnostic control system simons, 1995.
318 1397 394 825 507 295 862 703 1650 802 982 1585 247 1622 234 973 463 1502 1607 1288 422 170 90 1582 1390 1517 979 494 1496 1510 889 265 1211 376 958 182 656 115 1379